How proposals are grouped on this site
Form N-PX has no proposal number and no standard title. Each filer describes each matter in its own words.
One proposal can arrive as "Report on Lobbying Payments and Policy". It can arrive as Shareholder proposal regarding lobbying disclosure
. It can arrive as "Item 6". All three can mean the same line of the ballot.
To say how many filers voted for a proposal, the site must bring these records together.
Step one: category and source
The site first splits the records by who proposed the matter: the issuer or a security holder. Then it splits them by the 14 categories of the form.
Some items exist one time for each meeting. The site needs no text to find them:
- the advisory vote on executive pay;
- the vote on how often to hold it;
- the vote on pay tied to a merger;
- audit-related items.
A director election becomes counts. The counts are the number of nominees, the share of reported votes for, and the number of filers that withheld from at least one nominee.
The wording of a director record names a person. The site discards it when it has counted it.
Step two: other items of the company
The site shows the other items of the company together by category. Examples are share issues, equity plans and charter changes. Filers word and number them in different ways, and they are seldom contested.
Step three: proposals from security holders
Proposals from security holders are the contested part of a ballot. So the site separates them when the filings allow.
- The site reduces each description to its content words. It removes numbers and boilerplate such as "if properly presented".
- It links wordings that share enough content words. It starts with the wordings of the most filers.
- It keeps two wordings of one filer apart. A filer reports each proposal one time. So two wordings from one filer are two proposals.
- It merges groups from different sets of filers that overlap less strongly. Different voting platforms word one proposal in different ways.
- It does not show a group with too few filers as a proposal. It shows the records together as "shareholder proposals (not separable from the filings)".
Titles
The title of a group is its most common wording, shortened. A wording must pass a person-name filter before the site prints it. Some descriptions name the proponent or an executive.
The filter rejects a wording with a given name, an honorific or the phrase "submitted by". It rejects a wording about the election, appointment, pay or removal of an office holder. It rejects a word that appears mostly in such wordings. It rejects a word that is not in the general vocabulary of proposal wordings.
If no wording passes, the page shows the SEC category name.
What can go wrong
The site can merge two similar proposals when no filer reports both. It can split one proposal when platforms word it very differently. A filer can choose an unexpected category.
The corrections page tells you how to report a grouping error. Every filer page links to the filings.
Last checked against the SEC pages: .