Vote Scores
Filings read through

Why a fund's votes are not the meeting result

A company page on this site can show that a third of the reporting filers voted against management on executive pay. That is a fact about those filers. It does not tell you how the vote came out.

Who is missing

  • Holders that do not file. Individuals, founders and insiders do not file Form N-PX. Nor do most foreign investors.
  • Most of what managers vote. Institutional managers report say-on-pay votes only. Their votes on directors, mergers and proposals from security holders are not on the form. A registered fund can report them.
  • Shares on loan. A lender does not vote shares that are on loan at the record date.

Counting filers is not counting shares

The site shows a split in two ways: by the number of filers and by the shares that they reported.

Take a company where 90 small filers vote against and 10 very large filers vote for. By filer, 90% voted against. By shares, perhaps 10% voted against. Neither figure is the result.

The figure by shares is closer to the result. It still covers only the shares on the form.

Thresholds differ

Some matters need a majority of the votes cast. Some need a majority of the shares in issue. Some need a larger majority. An advisory vote binds nobody.

A full count of votes would still not settle the result without the rules of the company.

Where results are published

A company reports the voting results of a meeting on Form 8-K, Item 5.07. The form gives four business days, counted from the day the meeting ended. The company reports the preliminary results first and the final results after. Form 8-K (PDF)

This site does not read those filings yet. So no page here says whether a proposal was carried.

Last checked against the SEC pages: .