How to read "for or against management"
Every vote on Form N-PX carries two facts. One is how the shares were voted. The other is whether that vote was for or against the recommendation of management.
The SEC form asks for the second fact in these words:
Whether the votes disclosed in paragraph (k) represented votes for or against management’s recommendation;Form N-PX, Item 1(l)
The mark is not the recommendation of management on the matter. It says whether the filer went along with management.
Four cases
| Matter | Management said | Filer voted | Marked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Approve executive pay (issuer) | vote for | for | with management |
| Approve executive pay (issuer) | vote for | against | against management |
| Report on lobbying (security holder) | vote against | against | with management |
| Report on lobbying (security holder) | vote against | for | against management |
A filer that votes against every proposal from a security holder can show a low against-management share. The "against" part of a vote bar is not the same as the against-management share.
When management makes no recommendation
The SEC form tells the filer what to write in this case:
If management did not make a recommendation on how to vote on a particular matter, a reporting person should respond “none” to paragraph (l) of Item 1 for that matter.Form N-PX, Special Instruction D.8
This site leaves a vote with the mark "none" out of the against-management share. It also leaves out a vote with no mark.
The vote bar
Every vote split on this site has the same bar. The bar has three parts. An amber tick under the bar shows the part cast against management. It starts at the right end.
This example is made up. 82% of the votes are for, 15% are against and 3% are other. 9.6% of the votes with a management mark are against management.
The two "against" figures differ. Some votes against were with management, on proposals from security holders.
A field of the form, not a grade
The management mark puts items of the company and proposals from security holders on one scale. A share against management is a description. It says nothing about the quality of any voting. This site draws no such conclusion.
Follow a filed denominator
HARTFORD MUTUAL FUNDS, INC has 34,892 vote records in the year to 30 June 2026.
31,538 records are marked with management and 1,964 against management. Their sum, 33,502, is the denominator.
The against-management share is 5.9%. It excludes records with no management recommendation or no mark.
The filer record links the season CSV. Its total vote count and its management-mark denominator answer different questions.
Last checked against the SEC pages: .